I interrupt my regularly scheduled Hair Theory post to bring you this important message:
Every once in awhile I need to get serious on my blog because something just irks me. I hate the word 'irk' but I'm using it anyway because I'm so irked. The recent release of The Dark Knight Rises and people's subsequent reaction to it has caused me to start thinking. We are such movie snobs nowadays. (I also hate the word 'nowadays').
I've seen SO many people negatively review this movie just because it wasn't as good as the last one. First of all, WHAT?! What do you want people? How could Christopher Nolan have made this movie any better? What would have satisfied you? Please submit your suggestions. I'd love to hear them.
If you had wet yourself in the theater would you have been satisfied? This movie was still the best movie I've seen all year. And I refuse to pan it just because it wasn't "as good as the last one."
Which brings me to my next point. You can't compare these two movies. Yes, they were both Batman films, but that's about all they share in common. If Heath Ledger hadn't died, and Joker had made a return, and the plot had been boring, and the acting not as good, THEN I could see people saying, "This isn't as good as the last one." But again, other than having some of the same characters, they are completely different movies. Chris has managed to capture the nation's zeitgeist three times in a row. Each film in this series has a different and potent message about our society. I'm nerdy enough to admit the movie gave me chills 3 or 4 times.
So comparing the two movies is like... I feel like I'm already losing you, so I'll use an example that even the most... simple... can understand. Comparing these two movies is like comparing a Granny Smith apple with a Red Delicious. Both are apples, but they taste completely different, and when subjective preferences are cast aside, the two apples have different functions. Who can say which is better? Granny Smith are better for pies because of their tartness, and Red Delicious are preferred by most to pack in lunches. Get it? Stop comparing them, it makes you look ignorant because you've missed the deeper messages the films have been trying to deliver.
And finally, we are such snobs today. I would go so far as to say these three films are the Godfather Trilogy of our time. These films are fantastic. I can't stop thinking about TDKR. Yes, it had minor flaws like Bane's voice and a slightly over-complicated plot, but other than that it was superb. I want to see it again because I know I'll get deeper meanings out of it. Which I can't say for almost any movie I see. What do most people think when they walk out of a movie like Transformers? "Hmm, it had awesome visual effects." And then they forget it. It's throwaway entertainment. This is not the case for any of the Batman movies.
Stop being movie snobs. Even if you were to show our worst movies to people fifty years ago they would have brain aneurysms. Stop being so negative, and think for yourselves. Lighten up. After all, it is just a movie, isn't it?
[Keep Following.]
20 July 2012
03 June 2012
Hair Theory
Get ready to take a fantastic journey into the center of my mind. Ready?
I notice things about hair. Whether it be the length of a grandpa's wicked comb-over, or the amount of blue dye in a grandma's fro, I am unnaturally perceptive. It is my blessing, and my curse. Because of my wonderful ability to read hair, I have noticed an interesting hair pattern among the women in Utah. I would now like to present the 9 stages of women's hair:
1. Baby Bald Eagle
This is a stage that, to be fair, is not most girls' fault. Indeed, one could say that because of the sheer lack of hair in this stage, that it is barely a stage at all. But it must be mentioned simply out of sheer ridiculousness. Indeed, it is the lack of the hair that causes the stage seven mother (see #7) to overreact. This overreaction consists of placing a Gargantuan-flower-headband™ on the innocent victim to remind everyone of the gender of said victim. I don't know what mafia-funded company is supplying moms with these headbands, but I have a contact named Vinnie who believes that most of them are produced by a company that sulks in the seedy underbelly of society. Under the guise of homemade craft production, they fuel the mom's supply of overly enormous flower headbands. Vinnie calls the company code-name: Etsy. Furthermore, I believe that this stage causes irreparable damage to the female infant's psyche, thus perpetuating each consecutive stage.
2. My Little Pony Girl
Again, this stage may have less to do with the girls themselves, and more to do with the mothers who are beyond saving imposing their demented wills upon their female children. Little girls from ages 2-4 have been known to prance. They revel in their new-found "hair-i-ness" and for them the only logical reaction is to prance. For some reason, prancing is usually accompanied by hushed, mindless singing to themselves. At this stage, most girls have no concept of "dirt-i-ness" and can usually be found playing with the boys in the dirt. The only difference being that the girls somehow manage to include glitter with their dirt. How they do this is still a mystery. Consequently, out of a utilitarian attitude and lack of time, emerges the mom's quick and neat solution: the pony tail. Unfortunately, this hair style lends itself to prancing mindlessly about so well, that the moms have unwittingly furthered the cycle, pushing their scarred little girls toward madness.
3. "The Butch"
The breaking point comes usually before the girl's sixth birthday. As the availability of scissors increases above the girls' cognitive abilities, so rises the chance of having an "incident." It is a ruthless positive correlation. It looks something like this:
The incident is different for every girl, but after observing the patterns, several commonalities emerge. The first is the girls' desire to cut their hair. This desire emerges from one of two places: either out of a desire to be free from under the bondage of gum-and-glitter-caked hair, or from an apparent desire to become Boy George's hairstylist. Another commonality of this stage is the shared lack of guilt that the girls have for chopping a large chunk of hair from the front of their heads. The only explanation that I can think of is that the girls have not yet developed the "I look hideous" reflex. The effects of this reflex can most easily be observed whenever a girl gets her hair cut later in life. I don't think I've ever met a girl who has been content after visiting the salon. I believe this happens because girls have lingering scars from their butch moment. Deep down, they still feel as if they could cut their hair better than anyone else, and when someone else cuts it, they flashback to their personal "butch" moment and begin berate the stylist. (It has become a personal hobby of mine to ask the stylists who cut my hair about women's post-shear freak-outs.) Sometimes, again this stage is not directly the girls' fault. Sometimes they force their mothers hand into cutting their hair into a freakish mess by sticking copious amounts of Dubble Bubble in an all too conspicuous spot. Sometimes the mom has no other choice but to use the nuclear option, the all-dreaded Perm. I would now like to invite any girl readers to submit pictures of their personal butch moment to me so that I may further my research. And laugh my butt off. Probably not in that order.
[Keep Following. Part two is coming soon to an internet near you.]
I notice things about hair. Whether it be the length of a grandpa's wicked comb-over, or the amount of blue dye in a grandma's fro, I am unnaturally perceptive. It is my blessing, and my curse. Because of my wonderful ability to read hair, I have noticed an interesting hair pattern among the women in Utah. I would now like to present the 9 stages of women's hair:
1. Baby Bald Eagle
This is a stage that, to be fair, is not most girls' fault. Indeed, one could say that because of the sheer lack of hair in this stage, that it is barely a stage at all. But it must be mentioned simply out of sheer ridiculousness. Indeed, it is the lack of the hair that causes the stage seven mother (see #7) to overreact. This overreaction consists of placing a Gargantuan-flower-headband™ on the innocent victim to remind everyone of the gender of said victim. I don't know what mafia-funded company is supplying moms with these headbands, but I have a contact named Vinnie who believes that most of them are produced by a company that sulks in the seedy underbelly of society. Under the guise of homemade craft production, they fuel the mom's supply of overly enormous flower headbands. Vinnie calls the company code-name: Etsy. Furthermore, I believe that this stage causes irreparable damage to the female infant's psyche, thus perpetuating each consecutive stage.
![]() |
| "Seriously?" "Yes! She looks so cute!" "No, she looks scarred for life." |
2. My Little Pony Girl
Again, this stage may have less to do with the girls themselves, and more to do with the mothers who are beyond saving imposing their demented wills upon their female children. Little girls from ages 2-4 have been known to prance. They revel in their new-found "hair-i-ness" and for them the only logical reaction is to prance. For some reason, prancing is usually accompanied by hushed, mindless singing to themselves. At this stage, most girls have no concept of "dirt-i-ness" and can usually be found playing with the boys in the dirt. The only difference being that the girls somehow manage to include glitter with their dirt. How they do this is still a mystery. Consequently, out of a utilitarian attitude and lack of time, emerges the mom's quick and neat solution: the pony tail. Unfortunately, this hair style lends itself to prancing mindlessly about so well, that the moms have unwittingly furthered the cycle, pushing their scarred little girls toward madness.
![]() |
| Yes, it's quiet time. |
3. "The Butch"
The breaking point comes usually before the girl's sixth birthday. As the availability of scissors increases above the girls' cognitive abilities, so rises the chance of having an "incident." It is a ruthless positive correlation. It looks something like this:
![]() |
| Copyright DJ Scheerer. All rights reserved. |
The incident is different for every girl, but after observing the patterns, several commonalities emerge. The first is the girls' desire to cut their hair. This desire emerges from one of two places: either out of a desire to be free from under the bondage of gum-and-glitter-caked hair, or from an apparent desire to become Boy George's hairstylist. Another commonality of this stage is the shared lack of guilt that the girls have for chopping a large chunk of hair from the front of their heads. The only explanation that I can think of is that the girls have not yet developed the "I look hideous" reflex. The effects of this reflex can most easily be observed whenever a girl gets her hair cut later in life. I don't think I've ever met a girl who has been content after visiting the salon. I believe this happens because girls have lingering scars from their butch moment. Deep down, they still feel as if they could cut their hair better than anyone else, and when someone else cuts it, they flashback to their personal "butch" moment and begin berate the stylist. (It has become a personal hobby of mine to ask the stylists who cut my hair about women's post-shear freak-outs.) Sometimes, again this stage is not directly the girls' fault. Sometimes they force their mothers hand into cutting their hair into a freakish mess by sticking copious amounts of Dubble Bubble in an all too conspicuous spot. Sometimes the mom has no other choice but to use the nuclear option, the all-dreaded Perm. I would now like to invite any girl readers to submit pictures of their personal butch moment to me so that I may further my research. And laugh my butt off. Probably not in that order.
[Keep Following. Part two is coming soon to an internet near you.]
28 May 2012
Locked in Looming Shadows
I wrote this poem during Fall semester while having a hard day and while considering going away from the PhD and towards creative writing. I've decided it's pretty good and worth publishing--even if only my English major friends appreciate it.
Your ghosts--
They lie with me
in grey matter,
conspirators
of the worst kind.
They squelch my voice
with halting choke,
beat my brains out:
Literary
Dictators divine!
I see you would
frame me between
lines and pages,
Magnanimous--
up to a point.
"Here, no further
mayest thou go."
Never to be
anthologized
or widely read.
"Pay us homage
and perhaps then
we will write your
stone epitaph--
unworthy for water."
I can hear your
silent judgments--
nay, screaming fiery
admonitions--
wishing me unwell.
Leave me alone
Milton. Keats, please
withdraw your hand.
Shakespeare! Redact
thy airy nothings!
I would burn your
works, forsake them
to fire, and insert
stark emptiness
in their absence
To be able
to turn a phrase
without thy mean
influences--
maligning presences all.
Generations
wallow in your
slick afterbirth.
We are raised up,
but doomed to fail.
[Keep Following. I'm perfecting a theory on women's hair.]
Your ghosts--
They lie with me
in grey matter,
conspirators
of the worst kind.
They squelch my voice
with halting choke,
beat my brains out:
Literary
Dictators divine!
I see you would
frame me between
lines and pages,
Magnanimous--
up to a point.
"Here, no further
mayest thou go."
Never to be
anthologized
or widely read.
"Pay us homage
and perhaps then
we will write your
stone epitaph--
unworthy for water."
I can hear your
silent judgments--
nay, screaming fiery
admonitions--
wishing me unwell.
Leave me alone
Milton. Keats, please
withdraw your hand.
Shakespeare! Redact
thy airy nothings!
I would burn your
works, forsake them
to fire, and insert
stark emptiness
in their absence
To be able
to turn a phrase
without thy mean
influences--
maligning presences all.
Generations
wallow in your
slick afterbirth.
We are raised up,
but doomed to fail.
[Keep Following. I'm perfecting a theory on women's hair.]
15 March 2012
Why I Hate Basketball.
First of all the NBA.
Why would I want to watch a bunch of freaks of naturerun jog around a basketball court for two hours when the winner of the game is decided in the last five minutes of play anyway? This is more true in the NBA because the teams are so good that the "winner" is the team who happened to score last when the clock ran out. "WAIT," you say, "that is true of most sports!" With that I would have to agree.
But the difference is that it is much harder in every other sport to make points. In other sports, you win because you did some really hard thing to score. Not so in basketball. I trust no sport that has scores in the hundreds when the time runs out. If you knew nothing about basketball and all you knew was that the final score was 103 to 101 at the end, you would assume that 1. it must not be very hard to score points and 2. both teams are evenly matched. These two facts... *yawn* sorry, I almost just fell asleep on my keyboard.
The games should be five minutes long. It would make my life less tedious and watching a game wouldn't be a total waste of my time. Also, in other sports, especially football, you can be proud of your team's effort despite the outcome. In basketball I would be more mad at the clock and the nature of the game's flawed structure rather than my team if they lost. I would hate to play basketball, knowing that despite my best efforts, and despite staying within several points of the other teams score throughout the game, that oftentimes the result of the game would depend entirely on which team's center raised his arms above his head last. And he makes how much money?! How is the center's effort worth two points when a little guy shoots the ball from almost 25 feet away and gets only one more point for doing so? Points should be worth less if you are as tall as the hoop.
This brings me to College Basketball.
There isn't much to say except that the games are shorter. This is a great first step. The major reason I hate the NCAA is because of March madness. This single-elimination "tournament" embodies all the problems of the time limit flaw. Teams can be upset so easily and lose by only one point, such that any victory can't really be called anything of the sort. The winner of this tournament shouldn't get a trophy. They should all get four-leaf clovers for being so lucky so many times in a row.
This brings me to brackets. Bracket is the worst word in the English language. I hate all bros and their brackets. Because the tournament is completely based on luck, there is no point making predictions about who is going to win. I consistently hear the following statement after the tournament is over: "this chick in the office who knows nothing about basketball had the best bracket, bro!" That's because you have biases. And because you did a stupid thing.
All exaggerated cliches aside, you literally have a better chance of winning the lottery than filling out a perfect bracket. Like, a WAY better chance. The odds are ridiculous. "The point isn't to get it perfect, brah. The point is to get 'most of them right.'" Yeah, you know who else said something similar to that? The local trash fisher at the sewage treatment plant when talking about his short stint in grade school. If there is 0% chance of even getting most of the picks right, why try? Because of the nature of the system, picking winners is pointless. It would be like me trying to fish a lake with a gun from a mile away. And not only fishing, but predicting which fish I'm going to kill out of the 68 fish in the general vicinity.
30 MILLION people fill out a bracket each year. Stop it. I don't want to hear how your bracket is doing. I don't want to hear it because I already know. It sucks. You weren't even close.
[Keep Following.]
Why would I want to watch a bunch of freaks of nature
But the difference is that it is much harder in every other sport to make points. In other sports, you win because you did some really hard thing to score. Not so in basketball. I trust no sport that has scores in the hundreds when the time runs out. If you knew nothing about basketball and all you knew was that the final score was 103 to 101 at the end, you would assume that 1. it must not be very hard to score points and 2. both teams are evenly matched. These two facts... *yawn* sorry, I almost just fell asleep on my keyboard.
The games should be five minutes long. It would make my life less tedious and watching a game wouldn't be a total waste of my time. Also, in other sports, especially football, you can be proud of your team's effort despite the outcome. In basketball I would be more mad at the clock and the nature of the game's flawed structure rather than my team if they lost. I would hate to play basketball, knowing that despite my best efforts, and despite staying within several points of the other teams score throughout the game, that oftentimes the result of the game would depend entirely on which team's center raised his arms above his head last. And he makes how much money?! How is the center's effort worth two points when a little guy shoots the ball from almost 25 feet away and gets only one more point for doing so? Points should be worth less if you are as tall as the hoop.
I wonder what sport he plays?
Little known fact:
Those would be full length jeans on any other person.
This brings me to College Basketball.
There isn't much to say except that the games are shorter. This is a great first step. The major reason I hate the NCAA is because of March madness. This single-elimination "tournament" embodies all the problems of the time limit flaw. Teams can be upset so easily and lose by only one point, such that any victory can't really be called anything of the sort. The winner of this tournament shouldn't get a trophy. They should all get four-leaf clovers for being so lucky so many times in a row.
This brings me to brackets. Bracket is the worst word in the English language. I hate all bros and their brackets. Because the tournament is completely based on luck, there is no point making predictions about who is going to win. I consistently hear the following statement after the tournament is over: "this chick in the office who knows nothing about basketball had the best bracket, bro!" That's because you have biases. And because you did a stupid thing.
All exaggerated cliches aside, you literally have a better chance of winning the lottery than filling out a perfect bracket. Like, a WAY better chance. The odds are ridiculous. "The point isn't to get it perfect, brah. The point is to get 'most of them right.'" Yeah, you know who else said something similar to that? The local trash fisher at the sewage treatment plant when talking about his short stint in grade school. If there is 0% chance of even getting most of the picks right, why try? Because of the nature of the system, picking winners is pointless. It would be like me trying to fish a lake with a gun from a mile away. And not only fishing, but predicting which fish I'm going to kill out of the 68 fish in the general vicinity.
30 MILLION people fill out a bracket each year. Stop it. I don't want to hear how your bracket is doing. I don't want to hear it because I already know. It sucks. You weren't even close.
[Keep Following.]
15 December 2011
A Career Essay
I have come to this point in my college career and I must ask myself the all-important question why? I find that I am unhappy with where I am going and I know it's my fault. I suppose it started somewhere in high school. My mother wanted desperately for me to be successful (as all mothers do). She would suggest, from time to time, that I become a doctor or a scientist. I considered her words briefly. I thought of how nice it would be to have all the money I needed. I thought of how great it would be to provide all of the luxuries I could think of for my family. That is, I considered all this until my grades returned in Geometry, Physics, and Algebra II (which I only passed because I was "a good kid").
As you can imagine, this limited my choices, and I was left to decide between the soft sciences and the arts. Psychology, while interesting, was a little too perverted, history too boring, and political science sickening. My handwriting has always been poor and my drawings even worse. What, then, is a boy to do? Luckily, fate intervened, as she often does in stories like these, in the form of a creative writing teacher. On the last day of my senior year in high school she said to me, "You're insane if you don't go into a career in writing."
I shrugged off her advice as an errant compliment and kept on with my original career decision of becoming a computer programmer, which had always been a hobby of mine. After getting weeded by CS 101, and then not finding Print Journalism to my liking, I landed in the English major. Just another degenerate, forced into the amorphous degree that is barely one step above the General Studies major.
After coming to terms with where I was, I developed that artsy chip on my shoulder that broadcasts "I'm not in it for the money, I'm in it for the craft." I knew that all the others would work all their lives and I never would, because I enjoyed what I was learning and doing.
But now, four years later, I find myself caught in that same lie that I had been trying to get away from. That you can buy anything in this world for money. I had decided to get a PhD in Romantic Literature. I made a goal to get into a top school, I took a GRE prep course, and I bought books about grad school. In short, I was determined to become a highly respected and well paid Professor (an oxymoron though it may be). But while reading my books about grad school I became overwhelmed by the busywork, politicking, finagling, over-achieving, money, time, and overall ridiculousness of the process. So much so that it simply has made me question my own motivations. Basically, I had better be damn sure that this is what I want to do if I'm going to put myself through those things. I was overwhelmed by how emotionally and academically under-prepared I am for what I had planned to do.
And then to top it all off, the other day I was reading an essay by a top scholar in my chosen field and I found myself nauseated by what I was being forced to read. I tried to push away the thousand thoughts that assailed me to no avail. And after some further reflection on them, I cannot help but admit their validity. These were the questions and thoughts that swirled around my brain about my career choice, about me, and about the essay that sat in my lap:
- What is the point of all this "literary analysis," "scholarship," and "research" drivel?
- Who cares?
- Why is this scholar writing? Is it really to be read by an exclusive elitist crowd who label themselves intellectual? More often than not, essays come across as exercises in intellectual masturbation rather than creative analysis out of love for the works themselves. And these scholars are the people that we as students should aspire to become?
- Did this person plan on becoming a stuffy critic when they first began their career? For indeed, Academe has turned being a Professor of Literature into a glorified literary critic (and I mean that in the worst sense). With the rise of Formalism and the need to be taken seriously, scholars sacrificed their love of literature for a false sense of acceptance in the world of education. Though they may couch their criticism in terms of comparison, analysis, and literary jargon, the only thing that differentiates them from modern critics is that they cite other critcs that came before them and use MLA format. All while making new "discoveries" about the past.
- I wanted to ask this professor, what drew you into being an english major in the first place? Was it the critical essays your teachers made you read? Or was it the literature? Was it discussing eternal and enlightening truths buried in the novel or poem, or was it the political games and ass-kissing required to gain acceptance among your peers?
I'll admit that these questions are rigged, but I would be so bold as to say that 99% of students and professors would answer these questions in the same way. And this isn't a new thing to me, I've known all along that I would have to sacrifice some of my creativity, or pay the piper in order to become a teacher, but it isn't until recently that I have actually started questioning whether or not it's worth it.
No one becomes an english major because they like writing stuffy academic prose or because they appreciate the mazes of "educated" jargon and gobbledygook that pervade millions of books and essays. But as a result of the acceptance of wordy blather in the PhD community, English majors are slowly chastised and coerced into writing and thinking this way because Professors are seeking to clone themselves.
Consequently, I would also be so bold as to say that all English majors experience the "what the hell did I just read?" essay at least once. This is the essay that is so incomprehensible and try-hard that it ends up saying nothing at all in a very fancy way. Consider this passage from Mikhail Bakhtin:
"The strength and at the same time the limitations of such basic stylistic categories become apparent when such categories are seen as conditioned by specific historical destinies and by the task that an ideological discourse assumes. These categories arose from and were shaped by the historically "aktuell" forces at work in the verbal-ideological evolution of specific social groups; they comprised the theoretical express of actualizing forces that were in the process of creating a life for language."
I rest my case. He might be saying some wonderful and grand things, but the only people willing to take the time to unpack that mess are professors with nothing better to do, and no talent for actually "creating a life for language."
My point is that I am done pretending not to care about money while inserting myself into a career path simply for the money and not because I love it. At first, when nothing was at stake in the 100 and 200 level courses I had fun immersing myself in the literature. But now that things are more serious and I encounter more jaded professors trying to groom their students into literary cronies by grading them down for not being "like them," I find that I am unhappy. What I mean is that I am no longer graded on the originality or merit of my ideas, but on how well I conform to the rigors of the academic prose, "proper form," and that muddy term they label "scholarship." I could say the same thing that has been written a thousand times and still get an A if I make it dense enough.
Granted, there are professors out there who haven't lost the vision, and to those last few brave souls, I applaud you. What I guess I'm really saying is that I am going back to writing. Not for anyone else, or for money, but because I love it, I'm good at it, and it makes me happy. And if I must provide for a family, I'll do this.
[Keep Following. It's about to get all kinds of active up in hee.]
As you can imagine, this limited my choices, and I was left to decide between the soft sciences and the arts. Psychology, while interesting, was a little too perverted, history too boring, and political science sickening. My handwriting has always been poor and my drawings even worse. What, then, is a boy to do? Luckily, fate intervened, as she often does in stories like these, in the form of a creative writing teacher. On the last day of my senior year in high school she said to me, "You're insane if you don't go into a career in writing."
I shrugged off her advice as an errant compliment and kept on with my original career decision of becoming a computer programmer, which had always been a hobby of mine. After getting weeded by CS 101, and then not finding Print Journalism to my liking, I landed in the English major. Just another degenerate, forced into the amorphous degree that is barely one step above the General Studies major.
After coming to terms with where I was, I developed that artsy chip on my shoulder that broadcasts "I'm not in it for the money, I'm in it for the craft." I knew that all the others would work all their lives and I never would, because I enjoyed what I was learning and doing.
But now, four years later, I find myself caught in that same lie that I had been trying to get away from. That you can buy anything in this world for money. I had decided to get a PhD in Romantic Literature. I made a goal to get into a top school, I took a GRE prep course, and I bought books about grad school. In short, I was determined to become a highly respected and well paid Professor (an oxymoron though it may be). But while reading my books about grad school I became overwhelmed by the busywork, politicking, finagling, over-achieving, money, time, and overall ridiculousness of the process. So much so that it simply has made me question my own motivations. Basically, I had better be damn sure that this is what I want to do if I'm going to put myself through those things. I was overwhelmed by how emotionally and academically under-prepared I am for what I had planned to do.
And then to top it all off, the other day I was reading an essay by a top scholar in my chosen field and I found myself nauseated by what I was being forced to read. I tried to push away the thousand thoughts that assailed me to no avail. And after some further reflection on them, I cannot help but admit their validity. These were the questions and thoughts that swirled around my brain about my career choice, about me, and about the essay that sat in my lap:
- What is the point of all this "literary analysis," "scholarship," and "research" drivel?
- Who cares?
- Why is this scholar writing? Is it really to be read by an exclusive elitist crowd who label themselves intellectual? More often than not, essays come across as exercises in intellectual masturbation rather than creative analysis out of love for the works themselves. And these scholars are the people that we as students should aspire to become?
- Did this person plan on becoming a stuffy critic when they first began their career? For indeed, Academe has turned being a Professor of Literature into a glorified literary critic (and I mean that in the worst sense). With the rise of Formalism and the need to be taken seriously, scholars sacrificed their love of literature for a false sense of acceptance in the world of education. Though they may couch their criticism in terms of comparison, analysis, and literary jargon, the only thing that differentiates them from modern critics is that they cite other critcs that came before them and use MLA format. All while making new "discoveries" about the past.
- I wanted to ask this professor, what drew you into being an english major in the first place? Was it the critical essays your teachers made you read? Or was it the literature? Was it discussing eternal and enlightening truths buried in the novel or poem, or was it the political games and ass-kissing required to gain acceptance among your peers?
I'll admit that these questions are rigged, but I would be so bold as to say that 99% of students and professors would answer these questions in the same way. And this isn't a new thing to me, I've known all along that I would have to sacrifice some of my creativity, or pay the piper in order to become a teacher, but it isn't until recently that I have actually started questioning whether or not it's worth it.
No one becomes an english major because they like writing stuffy academic prose or because they appreciate the mazes of "educated" jargon and gobbledygook that pervade millions of books and essays. But as a result of the acceptance of wordy blather in the PhD community, English majors are slowly chastised and coerced into writing and thinking this way because Professors are seeking to clone themselves.
Consequently, I would also be so bold as to say that all English majors experience the "what the hell did I just read?" essay at least once. This is the essay that is so incomprehensible and try-hard that it ends up saying nothing at all in a very fancy way. Consider this passage from Mikhail Bakhtin:
"The strength and at the same time the limitations of such basic stylistic categories become apparent when such categories are seen as conditioned by specific historical destinies and by the task that an ideological discourse assumes. These categories arose from and were shaped by the historically "aktuell" forces at work in the verbal-ideological evolution of specific social groups; they comprised the theoretical express of actualizing forces that were in the process of creating a life for language."
I rest my case. He might be saying some wonderful and grand things, but the only people willing to take the time to unpack that mess are professors with nothing better to do, and no talent for actually "creating a life for language."
My point is that I am done pretending not to care about money while inserting myself into a career path simply for the money and not because I love it. At first, when nothing was at stake in the 100 and 200 level courses I had fun immersing myself in the literature. But now that things are more serious and I encounter more jaded professors trying to groom their students into literary cronies by grading them down for not being "like them," I find that I am unhappy. What I mean is that I am no longer graded on the originality or merit of my ideas, but on how well I conform to the rigors of the academic prose, "proper form," and that muddy term they label "scholarship." I could say the same thing that has been written a thousand times and still get an A if I make it dense enough.
Granted, there are professors out there who haven't lost the vision, and to those last few brave souls, I applaud you. What I guess I'm really saying is that I am going back to writing. Not for anyone else, or for money, but because I love it, I'm good at it, and it makes me happy. And if I must provide for a family, I'll do this.
[Keep Following. It's about to get all kinds of active up in hee.]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




